We got 100 comments on the silly Snowden Sack… Which was a 100% failure. Or so I thought. I did some testing, and it turns out I’m probably going to be able to redeem the mylar Snowden Sack! Here were various tests:
- Put phone in all clad pot with lid: Didn’t ring.
- Put phone in Snowden sack. Rang. Tie to get a better seal: Rang.
- Put phone in all clad pot, covered with an el cheapo disposable aluminum pie plate. Rang.
- Wrapped phone in left over torn aluminum foil. Rang.
Things were looking bad. So, yesterday, when Jim left for New York, I went out and bought provisions which included heavy duty aluminum foil. Then Jim’s flight was cancelled, he came home, tests were delayed. Tests were resumed this morning.
- I wrapped the phone in 4 layers of aluminum and folded to create a seal: Phone did not ring.

- I progressively unwrapped, testing with 3, 2, 1 layers, each time taking care edges were sealed. Phone did not ring.
- I retested doing a “bad” job by not folding over the edges to seal: Phone rang. Clearly, the sealing at the edges
I did a number of tests sealing “well” and “fairly badly”, and concluded that imperfections in sealing were a big issue. I know some of you guys already knew this. But anyway, as a practical matter, if I very carefully smooth the foil and press the edges to get very good smooth contact, that seems to be “good enough” for this phone. I don’t seem to actually need to fold the edges of the foil over on itself.
But if I just wrap the phone and don’t take pains to press the foil very, very firmly leaving even a tiny gap, the phone rings.
So, then looking at my Snowden bag, I thought… maybe it’s the seal? I then got the brilliant idea to fold over the edges on the Snowden sack:
. The phone did not ring. I retested a few times: The phone does not ring provided I am very, very careful to make sure the edges stay well folded over. If I don’t hold the fold over edges carefully to make sure they truly fold, it rings.
I’m not absolutely positive this is due to the “folding over”. There is a possibility that mylar is just boderline effective. But it at least appears the issue is not the mylar, which seems to attenuate sufficiently for this puny phone operating in my kitchen. But clearly the seaming at the edges is not insufficient because the bag never works if the side eges aren’t folded over. Knowing this permits me some ideas I can test out. After all, my design criteria are
- Pretty easy to sew.
- Use cheap lightweight left over material I already have at hand. (As opposed to ordering materials that may or may not work.)
- Easy to stuff phone into pouch.
- Attenuates sufficiently to interfere with communication with local tower.
- Fits phone.
For now, I’m going to go upstairs, cut some scraps and bind the edges with mylar backed fabric. (I had cannibalized and just used a think single strip of blue fabric laid over two pieces pressed together )
This thing is going to get very ugly before the final halfway decent design exists.









